ShelfAudit vs Plug In SEO
ShelfAudit is the only Shopify tool with AEO scoring and one-click AI fixes. Plug In SEO has brand trust and simplicity. Here's the honest breakdown.
| Feature | ShelfAudit | Plug In SEO |
|---|---|---|
| SEO Audit | ✓Free | ✓ |
| AEO Score | ✓Free | ✗ |
| AI-Powered Fixes | ✓Starter+ | ✗ |
| One-Click Apply | ✓Starter+ | ✗ |
| Product-Level Audit | ✓Free | ✓ |
| Weekly Monitoring | ✓Starter+ | ✗ |
| Google Search Console | ✓Growth+ | ✗ |
| Free Plan | ✓ | ✓ |
| Price starts at | $0 | $9 |
Where ShelfAudit Wins
AEO Scoring for AI Search
ShelfAudit scores every product on AEO readiness — how likely it is to appear in ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews. Plug In SEO focuses only on traditional Google SEO and has no AEO scoring at all.
AI Rewrites, One Click Applied
ShelfAudit rewrites your titles and descriptions with AI, then pushes them directly to Shopify with one click. Plug In SEO shows you issues but requires manual fixes — you still have to write the copy yourself.
Weekly Automatic Re-Scans
ShelfAudit rescans your entire store every week and emails you a summary of new issues. Plug In SEO requires you to manually trigger audits — there's no automatic monitoring.
Where Plug In SEO Wins
1,000+ App Store Reviews
Plug In SEO has been around since 2012 and has built serious social proof on the Shopify App Store. If brand trust is your primary concern, that track record matters.
Simpler Setup
Plug In SEO has a very beginner-friendly interface with guided setup. If you're new to SEO and want something to get started in under 5 minutes, it's a solid starting point.
Bottom Line
If you want AEO scoring, AI-powered content fixes, and one-click apply to Shopify — ShelfAudit is the only choice. If you're a complete beginner who wants a simple, established tool with lots of reviews, Plug In SEO is a solid starting point. Most growing stores eventually need what ShelfAudit offers.
Try ShelfAudit free — no credit card needed
Audit up to 10 products, see your SEO and AEO scores, and compare against Plug In SEO yourself.
Start Free Audit